SF Examiner: Niners' QB questions linger after Smith’s rocky season

By Art Spander
Special to The Examiner


SAN FRANCISCO — With one game left in the 49ers’ season of “What do you mean we haven’t made progress?” here are unavoidable conclusions about young Alex Smith, the quarterback who keeps getting his passes batted down by lineman and his future kicked around by journalists.

Read the full story here.

Copyright 2009 SF Newspaper Company

Alex on Niners: It wasn't like we were inept

By Art Spander

SAN FRANCISCO -- It didn't rain. Two thirds of the seats had people in them. And the 49ers won. And you thought sportswriters only emphasize the negative.

Let those guys in Detroit pick on the Lions. Which they've done. And they will do. "Three wins in three seasons," one of the Detroit scribes moaned in the elevator at Candlestick Park.

The 49ers are better than that. But not good enough for the postseason. They keep making you wonder if and when they'll reach that pinnacle.

Alex Smith, who's supposed to lead the offense, got a bit defensive  Sunday when someone wondered why San Francisco started slowly against Detroit.

"It wasn't like we were inept or anything," mused the quarterback.

Not when compared to the Lions. They are inept.

They also have the worst defense in the NFL, ranking 32nd of the 32 teams, allowing 31 points and 396 yards a game. So when the Niners finished with 310 yards and a 20-6 victory, questions had to be asked. That they will remain unanswered is just part of the equation.

The question about the lack of fans is easily solved. No matter that the "paid attendance" was listed at 69,732, there were no more than 45,000 -- and maybe around 42,000.

That's understandable for a game between the now 2-13 Lions and the now 7-8 Niners held two days after Christmas. Even if it was the home finale.

The Niners won't be back at Candlestick until August, and what changes will have been made, what players added or subtracted, we'll have months to learn.

San Francisco's last game of the season-which-might-have-been is Sunday at St. Louis against the 1-13 Rams. The word "inept" also is applicable in their case.

Although Smith suggested the Niners offense Sunday wasn't as bad as it appeared, San Francisco's defense won the game, as it has won a few games over the last three months.

There were three interceptions and three fumble recoveries, enough turnovers to stagger even the Patriots or Colts and certainly enough to be the ruination of a team already close to ruination, even if it doesn't give up the ball.

"Hopefully," Niners coach Mike Singletary explained, "they (the takeaways) will be the trademark of any defense we have. You can't really achieve things that you want to achieve as a defense unless you take away the ball. That's when teams turn around. It really makes a difference.

"You can look at any game we won this year, and there's a pretty good chance we won the turnover ratio."

When you look at this one, you are no nearer deciding whether Alex Smith will be the essential quarterback, whether he can win games and not just keep the Niners from losing them.

Was the sputtering offense, two field goals and no touchdowns in the first half, Alex's fault? Or the fault of the offensive line? Or the fault of the play calling and decisions of coordinator Jimmy Raye? Or any combination thereof?

Frank Gore did run for 71 yards, and became the first Niner ever to rush for 1,000 yards or more for four straight years. Vernon Davis did catch three more balls, one of those for his 10th touchdown reception, a single-season Niner mark for tight ends. Yet, there are problems.

"Could it be because of distractions of the holidays?" Singletary asked rhetorically of the offense before halftime, "or are we still in a funk because we're not playing for a playoff position? It might be a number of things, but we picked up in the second half."

Smith was less discontent. He completed 20 of 31 for 230 yards and a touchdown, and didn’t have an interception, solid if not outstanding. No apparent mistakes, which always works for a quarterback at any level.

"I didn't think it was a slow start," said Smith in rebuttal to someone's query, "anywhere except on the scoreboard. We were doing some things, moving the ball, kicking two field goals. We didn't convert on fourth and one and missed a field goal (the kicker was just-signed Ricky Schmitt). If you convert one or two of those, it's a completely different game."

But they didn't convert one or two of those.

The Niners' first touchdown, in the third quarter, was a play perplexing enough for Singletary to say he would have those involved, Smith and Davis, come to a room for a bit of conversation. On third and goal from the Detroit two, Alex swept right and seemed destined for the end zone. But just as he arrived at the line of scrimmage, Smith tossed a moon ball to Davis in the corner.

"I need to find out if Vernon needed another touchdown, something like that," Singletary said. "Because Alex came to the sideline, and I scratched my head, and he knew what I was going to say. He said, 'Coach, be nice, be nice.'"

Will Singletary? "It depends what the answer is. If the right answer is, 'Vernon really wanted one,' I can live with that."

For now, Singletary and the Niners will have to live with a win over the Lions. Sure, virtually everybody has one of those, but it's still acceptable, even mandatory.

L.A. Daily News: Carroll, Trojans get a feel-good ending with triumph in Emerald Bowl

By Art Spander
Special to the Daily News


SAN FRANCISCO -- It was a win. In the town where he was born. In the stadium where Barry Bonds broke the home run record. That was enough for Pete Carroll, even if might not been enough for those critics who call themselves USC fans.

Read the full story here.

Copyright 2009 Los Angeles Newspaper Group

RealClearSports: Bay Area Full of Dysfunction

By Art Spander
For RealClearSports.com


SAN FRANCISCO -- That the San Francisco 49ers are telling us they could play in Oakland, while the Oakland Athletics are more than hinting they want to play in San Jose, might not make sense to people back in the rust belt. Yet it's perfectly logical to us demented folk along the Pacific.

Read the full story here.

© RealClearSports 2009

SF Examiner: Carroll endures a rare rough season at Southern Cal

By Art Spander
Special to The Examiner


SAN FRANCISCO — Pete Carroll is making the best of it, which always has been his way. The letter writers in L.A. are down on him, because lately he hasn’t done what they wanted. Pete’s even a little down on himself, not that the enthusiasm doesn’t wash over the disappointment in a second or two.

Read the full story here.

Copyright 2009 SF Newspaper Company

RealClearSports: Randy Moss Is Up to His Old Tricks

By Art Spander
For RealClearSports.com


He showed up in a limousine, with an escort of seven police officers. Randy Moss made a grand entrance his first day with the Oakland Raiders, proclaiming, "Who wouldn't want to be in silver and black?''

Two years later, April 2007, the answer was Randy Moss.

Read the full story here.

© RealClearSports 2009

SF Examiner: 49ers on their way to recapturing glory

By Art Spander
Special to The Examiner


There was a feel of the ’80s at Candlestick on Monday. Not only because Alex Smith was kneeling down as the clock ran out. Not only because the crowd was screaming, noise that reverberated back into time, but because the 49ers played the way they once played — and presumably may play again.

Read the full story here.

Copyright 2009 SF Newspaper Company

JaMarcus blows his second act

OAKLAND -- A few days earlier, the lilt and the optimism had returned. JaMarcus Russell, the disappointment, faced the media and the music.

“There’s better days to come,’’ Russell finally said of his earlier demotion from the starting lineup. “Just move on with it.’’

What a great introduction for his second act, whenever that might arrive. JaMarcus was dealing with his failings, dealing with reality, understanding that when you’re the No. 1 pick in the draft, when you’ve been given a contract guaranteeing $31 million, the demands are high and patience short.

The opportunity arrived Sunday, in the gloom and rain of the Oakland Coliseum. Bruce Gradkowski, who had taken over, and successfully, for Russell a month earlier, went down with medial cartilage damage in both knees. Now, unexpectedly, the Oakland Raiders again were JaMarcus’ team.

He couldn’t produce. It wasn’t only Russell’s fault. The Raider offensive line couldn’t block. But when Gradkowski left, Oakland still was in the game, trailing 17-10 at the half. And then, seemingly becoming dispirited and definitely becoming disoriented, the Raiders collapsed.

Maybe it was the incessant booing from the announced crowd of 44,506, Raider fans already deciding Russell would be their target, especially when his passes can’t find their target. Maybe it was the situation, and the O-line, JaMarcus getting sacked six times, when Gradkowski only got nailed twice. Maybe it’s JaMarcus Russell, who in his third season gives no indication he’ll ever be a competent NFL quarterback, no matter his salary or ranking in the draft.

With Russell in there, the Raiders were out of there, eventually getting beat 34-13 by the Washington Redskins, one of the few teams with a record worse than Oakland’s. Until the game. Now both are 4-9. And now the questions about Russell’s progress are even more unavoidable.

JaMarcus just can’t escape the rush. He takes too long to find a receiver. He is immobile. And, of course, added to the problem, he plays for the Raiders, a franchise destined to have an 11-loss season for a seventh consecutive season.

“I thought it was a tough situation,’’ Raiders coach Tom Cable said of JaMarcus. “Could he have done better? Probably, but everybody could have.’’

Indeed, this was a team loss. Eight sacks in all. Fourteen penalties for 118 yards, two of those, each at 15 -- one for not giving enough space for a fair catch of a punt, the second for arguing the call -- at the same time late in the second quarter.

The 30 yards moved the Redskins from the spot of the catch, their own 10, to their own 40. In four plays, they swept to the touchdown that broke a 10-10 tie and seemingly broke what little resistance the Raiders had presented before that sequence.

“We had the opportunity to take another step forward,’’ said Cable, alluding to last Sunday’s upset of the Steelers and a blown chance to notch a second straight victory in 2009.

“We did not do that. We had too many penalties. There was not enough flow offensively. Defensively we struggled in the first half, and then we were never able to come back, make a stand, do anything in the second half.’’

Which is the half JaMarcus Russell played quarterback, throwing 16 passes, completing 10 for 74 yards, having the obligatory interception and, of course, getting sacked those six times for 52 yards.

Yes, Cable conceded, there was a discussion about pulling Russell and bringing in the third-stringer, Charlie Frye, meaning Russell could not return. But the Raiders stayed the course to oblivion.

When Gradkowski became the starter three weeks ago and the Raiders surprised the Bengals, the Raiders were uplifted. This guy, they implied, gives them the know-how and the electricity. He makes the other players better, as do all good quarterbacks.

When Russell moved in for the third quarter, the life went out of the Raiders. Maybe it was more perception than actuality, but it appeared they knew they were doomed. Which they were. Cable said he has confidence in “whoever we put out there or you can’t put them out there,’’ but do those on the field have confidence with JaMarcus?

“I think the guy can succeed,’’ Cable said of Russell. “I’ve not ever said he couldn’t.’’

Whether he means that is hard to discern. The fans may have given up on Russell -- you almost feel sorry for the way he’s treated -- but Raider management hasn’t. At least on the record. You think they’re going to stand up and say, “Sorry, folks, we were wrong’’?

Russell didn’t say anything after the game. He fled before the media entered the locker room.

Cable said the Raiders need to get “Russell where he needs to be,’’ and no, that isn’t on the sideline.

“Every quarterback is different,’’ Cable said. “Some guys get it quicker. Some guys take longer. We just have to keep working, helping him get where he wants to be. It’s a difficult position to play in this league.’’

For JaMarcus Russell, unfortunately, so far it’s an impossible position.

RealClearSports: Five Million for Mack Brown; That's America

By Art Spander
For RealClearSports.com


The University of Texas is giving a $2 million yearly boost to the man who (a) discovered a cure for cancer, (b) created an infallible program to end the violence in the Mideast, or (c) coached a football team into the national championship game.

It's not the fault of Mack Brown, who will be receiving $5 million annually, that his specialization is teaching kids how to score touchdowns or, need be, keep others from scoring them instead of teaching them to score on an exam.

It's the educational system's fault.

Read the full story here.

© RealClearSports 2009

SF Examiner: Smith is redeeming himself in the eyes of Niners fans

By Art Spander
Special to The Examiner


SANTA CLARA — The kid the 49ers could have picked had a fine game Monday night. Aaron Rodgers made us think of what might have been. The kid the Niners did pick was no less impressive the previous day.

You still can debate whether the Niners in the 2005 draft should have gone for Rodgers, playing across the Bay at Cal. We can no longer debate whether they should have not taken Alex Smith.

Read the full story here.

Copyright 2009 SF Newspaper Company

RealClearSports: USC Rubs It in Against UCLA

By Art Spander
For RealClearSports.com


LOS ANGELES -- Pete Carroll said it was only because he has the heart of a competitor. So, leading by a couple of touchdowns, with less than a minute to play, USC went deep. Into UCLA's heart.

Another touchdown for the Trojans. Another blow to the Bruins. And almost another one of those brawls which are an embarrassment to college football.

Read the full story here.

© RealClearSports 2009

SF Examiner: Singletary still has work to do

By Art Spander
Special to The Examiner

His phrase was “the enemy within,” an apt description of the opponent the 49ers, as any team where losing has been the norm, must learn to defeat before consistently defeating other teams.

We had a whiff of the idea from Mike Nolan, who perhaps went about it a little too vociferously. Losers think like losers. Winners, to the contrary, believe they will win.

Now we find Mike Singletary, all motivation and emotion, pounding even harder on the theme established by the man he replaced 13 months ago: The culture must change before the record will change.

Read the full story here.

Copyright 2009 SF Newspaper Company

Gradkowski might make it last

OAKLAND -- He was talking about the team, about the Oakland Raiders. “Ultimately,’’ said Bruce Gradkowski, “we can make this last.’’ He just as well could have been speaking about himself.

Maybe this time, Gradkowski finds permanence as an NFL quarterback. Maybe this time, he ends up on a roster instead of transactions.

“He’s just what a quarterback should be,’’ said Raiders tackle Robert Gallery of Gradkowski. “Confident, has the trust of everybody, because he knows that he’s doing.’’

As opposed to the man he replaced, JaMarcus Russell, who was expected to do what on Sunday Bruce Gradkowski did, lead Oakland to a comeback victory, this one 20-17 over the Cincinnati Bengals.

If the Raiders made a bad choice in Russell, the No. 1 selection in the 2007 NFL draft, they made a wonderful choice in Gradkowski, signed as a free agent after being dismissed by three other teams in the preceding year.

Ultimately, maybe they can make it last, the Raiders and Gradkowski, a team that has been for years wallowing in the lower depths and a quarterback who has to keep proving himself.

There’s some pedigree. The 26-year-old Gradkowski was a star in the same West Pennsylvania high school league as Joe Montana, Dan Marino, Joe Namath and Johnny Unitas. Taken in the sixth round of the 2006 draft by Tampa Bay, he became a starter and then an afterthought, going to St. Louis and Cleveland in an un-merry-go-round.

“That’s how the NFL is,’’ said Gradkowski, who played his college ball at Toledo. “You shift around here and there, and finally you catch on and get a break.’’

Sometimes that depends on whether your receivers catch a ball, which is what two Raider rookies did at very significant times against a Bengals team eight days from a win over the Steelers.

Darrius Heyward-Bey, of whom it was said early on had more names than catches, made a grab of a Gradkowski ball early in the third quarter on a third-and-three play of a drive that culminated with a Sebastian Janikowski field goal.

Later, with Oakland behind 17-10 and only a half-minute remaining, Louis Murphy made a beautiful over-the-shoulder reception and pushed over the goal for a 29-yard touchdown that tied the score.

A Cincinnati fumble on the subsequent kickoff, and a Raider recovery, enabled Janikowski to kick the 33-yard game-winning field goal.

For the first time in four games, the Raiders had a victory. For the first time since the season's opening week, the Raiders had more than one touchdown.

For the first time all season, it seemed the Raiders had a quarterback on whom they could depend.

“He looked pretty good,’’ Raiders coach Tom Cable said of Gradkowski.  So, too, did Cable, who after replacing Russell last week for a second straight game made the decision in mid-week to go with Gradkowski in the opening lineup.

“I thought he was too amped up early in the game,’’ said Cable. “But that’s what I expected. He needed to settle down. But after, he was pretty darn good . . . and I don’t know if you can ask for a better closing drive.’’

It was the stuff of Montana, or Tom Brady or Peyton Manning.  It started on the Raiders' 20 with 2:12 remaining and included a fourth-and-10 pass for 29 yards to Chaz Schillens. Gradkowski spiked the ball and then threw the ball 29 yards to Murphy.

“He’s pretty calm,’’ Cable said of Gradkowski. “He goes out before a drive and has some thoughts with (the coaches). He knows where he’s headed. He’s into feedback. He’s into it the way you’re supposed to be.’’

Asked why Gradkowski had been signed and waived, signed and waived, Cable said, “You have to get things going right away in this business, very quickly, or you’re not around very long. That’s coaches, players, whatever.’’

Especially you’re if a sixth-rounder. If you’re the first guy taken in the draft and have a $32 million contract, as does JaMarcus Russell, you’re around perhaps longer than you should be.

Gradkowski showed up for the post-game interview dressed as if he going to a Hollywood party, in suit and tie. “Watch out for the glare off my head,’’ he joked, what hair that still remained having been shaved.

He explained that on the tying touchdown, Heyward-Bey was the first option but was covered. “I went through my progression,’’ said Gradkowski, “and saw the defensive back was on top of (Murphy), so I just kind of threw it the back shoulder. He made a great play. But if he didn’t get into the end zone, I was going to give him crap.’’

Something the Raiders had received more than enough of this season, and in recent seasons. But on this day, they were deserving of praise. And Bruce Gradkowski of getting that starting position as an NFL quarterback.

RealClearSports: Stanford Finds Out How Physical Cal Can Be

By Art Spander
For RealClearSports.com


STANFORD, Calif. -- It was won on the ground. And between the ears. It was all the physical battle everyone predicted and maybe every bit the mental one no one suspected.

Stanford was on a roll. "The hottest team in the country,'' insisted Cal coach Jeff Tedford. But in this 112th Big Game, Cal was hotter, more efficient, and considerably more effective.

Read the full story here.

© RealClearSports 2009

RealClearSports: Pete Carroll Cares, and Proves It

By Art Spander
For RealClearSports.com


LOS ANGELES -- The question came from the man who the past few days had been hearing too many of them.

This one, however, wasn't about how to repair a humbled football team, his team, USC.
Instead, it dealt with how we might repair a damaged society.

"Why should we care?'' asked Pete Carroll rhetorically.

Then he answered. "Because, we can change the culture.''


© RealClearSports 2009

RealClearSports: Belichick and Harbaugh Deserve Our Thanks

By Art Spander
For RealClearSports.com


SAN FRANCISCO -- So here was Jim Harbaugh, who tried to tell us he didn't want to take chances, going for a two-point conversion with his Stanford team far ahead, being linked to Bill Belichick, who as we know took one very large chance.

Harbaugh, the guy who just got an extension to stay at Stanford, and why not, since he proved kids who study are kids who can play, was about to step to the microphone in a bayside sports bar/brewery/dining establishment called Gordon Biersch.

Read the full story here.

© RealClearSports 2009

SF Examiner: Heisman hype has shifted from Best to Gerhart

By Art Spander
Special to The Examiner

SAN FRANCISCO — The Heisman Trophy often seems less a reward than a promotion. To be considered, you have to have talent, but you also have to have publicity, Hollywood-type stuff which catches the public’s imagination and schools hope catches the voters’ attention.


Cal went about it the right way with Jahvid Best, a superb running back, who played the hype game every bit as well as he played football, until he came crashing onto his head a couple of weeks ago, incurring a concussion which cost him not only any chance at the trophy, but also a chance at getting back on the field this season.


Now, it’s the guy across the Bay, Toby Gerhart of Stanford, who’s getting noticed, and while he won’t win it either, the shame is that two legitimate Heisman candidates could have been competing in the 112th Big Game on Saturday at Stanford Stadium.


Read the full story here.


Copyright 2009 SF Newspaper Company

Will it ever work for JaMarcus and the Raiders?

By Art Spander

OAKLAND -- He was supposed to the savior, the guy who dragged the Raiders from the mess they’re in, the quarterback who made the right calls and the proper throws. It hasn’t worked that way for JaMarcus Russell, and now, after he was benched a second straight game, you have to wonder if it ever will work.

So many factors, interconnected, inseparable, a bad football team, a questionable offense and then a young man who was the first selection in the draft and thereby supposed to correct the wrongs, supposed to turn the Oakland Raiders into winners.

But after the Raiders were beaten Sunday by one of the NFL’s other bad teams, the Kansas City Chiefs, 16- 10, a team over which Oakland had gained one of its only two victories this season, the future is more ink blot than window to success.

While it’s unforgiving to assign all the blame to JaMarcus -- his receivers offering little or no assistance, head coach Tom Cable counting eight dropped balls that should have been caught -- Russell has a great deal to do with the problem.

Or else Cable, for a second straight home game, wouldn’t have replaced him with Bruce Gradkowski.

And wouldn’t have conceded that he very well might start Gradkowski when the Raiders play Cincinnati next weekend, Cable adding that after watching the films he will have something more to say on that Monday.

Quarterbacks do not all develop at the same rate. Progress is relative. And those with potential invariably are taken by the bottom dwellers, the worst teams, meaning their baptism will be exceedingly painful. And yet it is the how and why of all this that adds to the doubt.

JaMarcus was a star at LSU with an arm able to launch rockets and a body (6-foot-6, 260 pounds , maybe 290) able to take punishment. He lacked finesse, polishing, but the belief was that it would come in the pros. He didn’t lack confidence, or after a long holdout ended and he signed for a $30 million guarantee, was that arrogance? Along with the tools Russell brought an attitude, or so it was perceived, the idea he was someone special. He isn’t.

He’s a struggling kid, the target of boos from a Raider fan base that seems to be shrinking by the week -- attendance at the Coliseum was only 40,720 -- but is not shrinking in its disdain for JaMarcus. Every wild pass was met with vocal derision.

This is JaMarcus’ third year, although he missed most of his rookie season, 2007, and the erratic performances are less baffling than they are irritating. Then again, maybe he’s not at fault -- if indeed he has worked to improve as Cable contends he has, it’s the Raiders who are at fault, for drafting him.

It’s the nature of sports, particularly the NFL, that a team chooses the athlete and then when he doesn’t live up to expectations, and there are no expectations higher than those for the very first pick every year, he gets the criticism, the boos, as opposed to the people who selected him.

Russell comes across as uncaring because he doesn’t scream and yell. He also doesn’t seem to grasp the mistakes, or at least doesn’t admit to them.

“I thought things were going OK at that point,’’ said JaMarcus, who was replaced late in the third quarter. Asked if he were disappointed, Russell said, “Totally. I really can’t explain it. I don’t know what to say. (Cable) said balls were going every which way, but one time my arm was hit when I threw.’’

What Cable said was that Russell, completing only 9 of 24 for 67 yards, misread several throws, two where receivers were unguarded. “It was a matter of game management and accuracy,’’ explained the coach.

It also was a matter of poor hands by his possible receivers or, and this isn’t shocking to anyone familiar with the Raiders, penalties. If Darrius Heyward-Bey or Louis Murphy hang on to a pass or two, maybe JaMarcus stays on the field.

“They affect you,’’ said Russell. “A couple of those aren’t dropped, it’s a totally different game.’’

By the time JaMarcus was taken out, the Raiders’ Shane Lechler had 10 punts, or one more than Russell had pass completions. Eventually, as a team, the Raiders, with Gradkowski going 4-for-7 and also having a couple of long passes dropped, would end with 13 completions. And 11 punts.

Asked if he were disappointed in Russell, Cable responded, “I’m disappointed where we are as a football team. This game is about making plays, and we just didn’t do it, whether it was JaMarcus or Bruce.’’

The Raiders have scored more than one touchdown only in one game this season, opening night. They ranked 32nd, dead last, in the league in offense. The Chiefs were 30th. And now both teams are 2-7.

And now JaMarcus Russell hasn’t finished two of the last three games he started.

“Some guys take longer than others,’’ Cable said, defending Russell. “He’ll get there at some point. He’s a talented guy.’’

But so far one without a clue how to play quarterback in the NFL.

RealClearSports: Cutler Turns Over a Victory to the 49ers

By Art Spander
For RealClearSports.com


SAN FRANCISCO -- In the future we're destined to have pro football eight days a week. It's unavoidable, like death and taxes. Fumbles, interceptions, holding penalties by the hour.

But right now it's only Sunday, Monday and, had we forgotten, Thursday night, that series now restarted to the delight of NFL Network if not the game's purists.

The San Francisco 49ers and Chicago Bears each played, and lost, Sunday, and then four days later, they were forced to face each other by the side of San Francisco Bay, two not very good teams offering a lot of not very good football.

Read the full story here.

© RealClearSports 2009